At Plain & Fancy Farm, dinner can begin with a tray of smoky brisket, a plate of fried chicken and mashed potatoes, or a two-meat barbecue platter that gives the table more than one direction to go. The Smokehouse brings together the big, familiar pleasures of a barbecue restaurant and the comfort-food appetite Lancaster County visitors tend to work up after a day out.
It is a relaxed, woodsy dining room with a country-restaurant spirit, table service and enough variety to accommodate the person intent on ribs as well as the one who would rather have meatloaf. The mood is easygoing, but the food is substantial.
A broad smokehouse menu
Smoked meats are the backbone of the menu: brisket, pulled pork, ribs, burnt ends, smoked turkey, smoked chicken and smoked prime rib all make appearances. Brisket has a notably smoky, flavorful profile, including a bit of char that barbecue fans tend to appreciate.
The two-meat combination platters are a practical way to explore the kitchen without having to make a single hard choice. Pair brisket with pulled pork, for example, then add sides and let the plate do the heavy lifting.
Burnt ends have their own place on the menu rather than being treated as an afterthought, and they are a worthwhile order for diners who enjoy the richer, deeply smoked side of barbecue. Smoked prime rib has also been offered as a special, bringing that familiar beefy prime-rib character together with smoke.
Sandwiches built for a serious appetite
Not every barbecue meal needs to arrive as a platter. The Smokehouse Stacker puts pulled pork together with bacon and pickles, a combination that gives the sandwich some crunch and tang alongside the meat.
Other sandwich-style choices have included a brisket cheesesteak, a prime rib sandwich and the bacon-topped Smokey Burger. These are useful alternatives for a lunch-sized visit or for anyone who wants the smokehouse flavor in a more handheld format.
Fried chicken and the comfort-food side of dinner
The restaurant does not ask every diner to commit to smoke and sauce. Fried chicken and meatloaf share the table with the barbecue, and fried chicken with buttery mashed potatoes remains a natural order for diners in the mood for old-fashioned comfort food.
Sides deserve their own attention here. Housemade macaroni and cheese, battered seasoned fries, coleslaw, cornbread or corn muffins, mashed potatoes and seasoned seasonal vegetables give a meal the familiar, generous spread that suits a family table.
Cheese curds arrive in round, fried pieces that have been compared to mozzarella sticks. They make an easy starter to set out before the main courses land.
Room for kids and a full table
The menu works well for a mixed-age group. Children have choices beyond barbecue, including macaroni and cheese and pasta with marinara, along with child-friendly beverages such as apple juice. Kids' menus and coloring pages help keep the wait for dinner pleasantly occupied.
For a larger meal, the restaurant has accommodated family groups at one large table, and separate checks have been handled for adult children dining together. A family-style meal for four has also been listed with fried chicken, meatloaf, sides, desserts and nonalcoholic drinks.
Portions generally run generous, particularly on the combination platters. The large brownie sundae is another order that makes sense in the middle of a table rather than at the end of one person's meal.
Dessert and a drink at the bar
Dessert can be as straightforwardly indulgent as strawberry cheesecake with a cookie-crumb crust, or that shareable brownie sundae. After a plate of ribs and macaroni and cheese, splitting dessert is not a bad arrangement.
A bar adds another lane to the visit, with mixed drinks, flights and other adult beverages available. It can be a comfortable meeting point before dinner or a place to settle in with a drink while the rest of the group decides between brisket and fried chicken.
Finding the dining room at Plain & Fancy Farm
The Smokehouse is part of the Plain & Fancy Farm complex rather than a standalone roadside building. Enter through the front doors and turn left toward the restaurant, following the route through or alongside the adjoining gift shop. The gift-shop passage is simply part of getting to the table.
Free parking is available in the shared lot used by the hotel and Plain & Fancy Farm complex. Because the property sits on an incline, the lot is divided across two levels and includes a short walk to the entrance.
The location fits neatly into a Lancaster County day of shopping, sightseeing or visiting the surrounding Plain & Fancy Farm attractions. Nearby hotel guests also have a convenient dinner option close at hand.
A few useful details before dinner
Reservations have been used for everything from small dinners to bigger family groups, especially when the room is likely to be busy. The dining room can be easy for conversation at some times and more animated at others, depending on the crowd.
Service has a welcoming, attentive reputation, and staff can discuss preparation details when guests have dietary questions, including whether certain foods are made in shared or dedicated spaces. Specific needs are best raised directly when ordering.
The appeal is uncomplicated: a warm room, a long list of smoked meats, familiar sides and enough menu range that a table does not have to agree on one style of dinner.
