A lobster roll has more than one way to make an entrance here. The menu offers several versions, including one dressed with brown butter and dill, a combination that gives the familiar sandwich a little extra richness and a bright herbal note.
That sense of choice runs through this Easton seafood restaurant. Lobster, crab, shrimp, scallops, oysters, cod, clams and fish-and-chips all have a place on the menu, but the kitchen does not stop at the standard greatest hits. You can settle into a straightforward seafood dinner or head toward a dish built around lobster in nearly every form imaginable.
The rooms keep the mood relaxed. Rustic nautical touches, booths, dining-room tables and a bar create a setting suited to a weekday lunch as easily as a birthday dinner. On quieter visits, conversation is easy; at busier times, the room has more energy.
Lobster goes well beyond the roll
The lobster-and-shrimp mac and cheese is a good example of the restaurant's more generous instincts. It is a seafood-forward dish rather than a basic macaroni side with a few token pieces stirred in, bringing substantial lobster and shrimp into a rich cheese sauce.
Lobster pie and lobster risotto offer two more directions for diners who want to make lobster the focus of dinner. There is also a pan-seared shrimp-and-scallop entrée paired with lobster risotto, which neatly solves the problem of choosing just one shellfish.
For an appetizer-sized introduction, lobster risotto bites arrive with a lobster-cheese sauce that has a bisque-like character. They are an easy shared starter, especially when the table plans to order across the menu rather than commit everybody to the same entrée.
Crab, shrimp and a sturdy fish dinner
Crab appears in plenty of forms, including crab legs, crab cakes and an especially indulgent order of crab pierogies. The pierogies come with lump crab, bacon and horseradish sauce, turning a comfort-food staple into something distinctly coastal.
The broiled seafood combination gives a broader sampling: scallops, cod and stuffed shrimp with crabmeat can all appear on the plate. Other preparations include garlic-seasoned broiled shrimp, shrimp scampi, baked cod and salmon en croute, so a diner need not be devoted to lobster to eat well here.
Fish-and-chips takes the casual route, with flaky fish beneath thin, crisp breading and hand-cut fries alongside. It is a substantial order, the sort of plate that can turn a simple lunch into a lingering meal.
The appetizer list supports a more informal approach, too. Clams casino, coconut shrimp, shrimp baskets and French onion soup leave room for a meal built around starters, while a sampler platter gives a larger table something to pass around before the entrées arrive.
Chowder and oysters before the main event
Chowder has enough presence here to merit its own decision. Manhattan clam chowder is available for diners who prefer its tomato-based style, while the seafood chowder brings white fish and clams into a creamier bowl. Chowder is even available by the quart for taking home, useful when a single bowl turns into a craving.
The oyster selection changes, and Blue Point oysters are among the varieties that have appeared. Staff can help explain the day's oyster choices, along with specials and preparation details, making the raw-bar decision less of a guessing game.
A meal that works around the table
Seafood may lead the menu, but it is not the only option. Non-seafood dishes and clearly identified vegetarian selections help when one member of the group is there for crab legs and another would rather not order fish at all. Gluten-free choices are also available, and some entrée modifications can be accommodated when requested.
That range helps explain the restaurant's use for family meals and celebrations. Couples can keep things simple at a booth or dining-room table, solo diners can eat at the bar, and larger parties have more room to spread out. A wall-side table can give a group some privacy without sending it off into a separate, hushed corner.
For bigger occasions, private dining rooms are available for large parties and special events. The bar also stands on its own as a comfortable place to have a full meal rather than merely wait for a table.
Leave room for dessert
Key lime pie provides the tart, cool finish that makes sense after a rich lobster dish or a bowl of chowder. Funnel cake takes a more playful direction, a little fairground-style flourish after a plate of broiled seafood.
The restaurant is in Easton, with a large free parking lot accessed from William Penn Highway. Reservations are available through OpenTable, and dinner can be busier than a casual lunch, particularly when celebrations and larger groups are in the mix. A rewards program is also available for diners who expect to return for another round of chowder, oysters or that brown-butter-dill roll.
